Updated November 2026
In August 2023, I wrote about Stephen Nolan, BBC Northern Ireland and the influence of repeated political appearances on our democracy.
Three years later, my concerns have not diminished. Indeed, I believe the case for examining the political influence of the Nolan programmes has become stronger.
At stake is the power of a publicly funded broadcaster to influence which political voices become familiar, credible and influential in Northern Ireland.
The TUV — From 20,523 Votes to 65,788
In the 2017 Northern Ireland Assembly election, the TUV received 20,523 first-preference votes, representing approximately 2.6% of the total. 2017 Northern Ireland Assembly election report
In 2022, it received 65,788 votes, representing 7.6%. That is an increase of 45,265 votes — a rise of more than 220%. Yet the TUV still elected only one MLA. 2022 Northern Ireland Assembly election report
During those intervening years, Jim Allister was a familiar and recurring voice on the Nolan programmes. I believe those appearances helped bring the TUV’s arguments to a wider audience and that their contribution to the party’s electoral growth deserves serious investigation.
Brexit, the Northern Ireland Protocol and dissatisfaction with the DUP all contributed to the TUV’s appeal. The election figures alone cannot tell us how much of the increase was due to broadcasting exposure. But how did the party’s arguments reach voters in the first place?
Political discontent does not automatically become electoral support. Voters must first hear the arguments, recognise the people making them and become familiar with their positions.
The Power of Repetition
I spent 35 years working in advertising and marketing communications. Businesses spend millions of pounds building awareness, recognition and familiarity.
They do so because repetition works.
When a product is advertised repeatedly, people become familiar with it. When they come to make a purchasing decision, that familiarity can influence their choice. The same principle of recognition matters in politics.
When a politician is repeatedly invited onto a prominent programme, the benefits extend beyond the particular argument being discussed.
The politician becomes familiar. Their opinions become familiar. Their presence becomes expected.
What Is That Airtime Worth?
In my original article, I used an illustrative commercial advertising rate of £1,000 per minute. On that basis, a fifteen-minute appearance would represent £15,000 of advertising-equivalent exposure. Four such appearances would represent £60,000. Four every month would represent £720,000 over a year.
Add television appearances and the wider publicity generated by a high media profile, and the illustrative value could approach £1 million annually.
These calculations use a hypothetical advertising rate to illustrate the potential value of repeated exposure. An editorial interview and a paid advertisement serve different purposes.
Media exposure is valuable. If it were not, political parties and commercial organisations would not invest so heavily in securing it.
And when that exposure is provided repeatedly by a publicly funded broadcaster, questions about its distribution are entirely legitimate.
The Electoral Imbalance
Here are the first-preference results for the six parties with the most votes in the 2022 Assembly election.
| Party | Votes | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Sinn Féin | 250,385 | 29.0% |
| DUP | 184,002 | 21.3% |
| Alliance | 116,681 | 13.5% |
| UUP | 96,390 | 11.2% |
| SDLP | 78,237 | 9.1% |
| TUV | 65,788 | 7.6% |
2022 Northern Ireland Assembly election report
Sinn Féin received almost four times the TUV vote. The DUP received almost three times as many votes. Alliance received approximately 1.8 times as many.
Does the distribution of political airtime reflect these differences? Electoral support is one consideration when assessing political representation over time. The news agenda matters too. An interview may be balanced in isolation while a pattern of appearances over several years creates a very different picture.
Jamie Bryson — The Power of Becoming a Familiar Voice
Jamie Bryson has no electoral mandate. Yet through repeated appearances in broadcasting and the wider media, he has become a recognisable contributor to political discussion in Northern Ireland.
I believe his appearances on the Nolan programmes have contributed significantly to that recognition. Reporting on someone’s activities because they are newsworthy serves a different purpose from repeatedly inviting that person to comment on political developments. Those invitations can help establish an activist as a commentator whose views are routinely sought. Once established, that status can lead to further appearances and wider public recognition.
Through its editorial choices, a broadcaster can help create the prominence of the people it covers.
The BBC Must Be Accountable
I previously raised my concerns directly with BBC Northern Ireland management. I was told that challenging Jim Allister with difficult questions was sufficient to address concerns about his appearances.
I disagreed then, and I disagree now. Even a tough interview gives a guest an opportunity to communicate their message. In some circumstances, confrontation may even strengthen the interviewee’s public profile.
The BBC’s own impartiality principles recognise the importance of giving appropriate weight to different political perspectives. The public should be able to see how that principle is applied across programmes and over time.
Publish the Figures — Let the Public Judge
I have called for BBC Northern Ireland to publish an independently verifiable record of political appearances on Nolan Live and The Nolan Show. That record should show:
- How often representatives of each political party appear and how many minutes they speak.
- How often regular unelected contributors appear and how much speaking time they receive.
- How airtime compares with electoral support and how its distribution changes over months and years.
We need those records to establish how airtime was distributed. They would also let us examine whether increased exposure coincided with the TUV’s electoral growth and how often particular contributors were invited back.
The public should have access to the evidence needed to assess the BBC’s editorial decisions independently.
Publish the appearances. Publish the minutes. Publish the comparisons.
Then let the public judge.
Why This Matters More Than Ever
The Nolan programmes discuss political decisions, public institutions, identity, community relations and the future of Northern Ireland. Those discussions can shape which issues attract attention and which arguments the public hears.
Our society has experienced decades of division and conflict. The Good Friday Agreement was intended to create institutions based on democratic participation, equality and respect. Public-service broadcasting has an important role in that environment. It should facilitate informed discussion across the full range of political opinion.
We pay for the BBC. We are entitled to know how its editorial decisions are made and whether the broadcaster is fulfilling its duty to the whole community.
The BBC has helped determine whose voices Northern Ireland hears most often. It is time we knew precisely who received that exposure, how much they received, and what influence it may have had.

Leave a Reply